Custom Cakes

Thank you for considering Squares for your next celebration!

For our cakes, it is recommended to order 1-2 weeks in advance. Any order placed within 2 days of due date may be assessed a rush fee. For tiered cakes, it is recommended to order at least 3-4 weeks in advance.

After submitting your inquiry, you will be contacted within 24 - 48 hours. Please note that submitting an inquiry form does not guarantee a reservation. Full payments must be made to confirm your order date.

Below are our starting prices for our buttercream round and heart-shaped cakes, tiered cakes, and sheet cakes. All cakes are priced individually based on flavor, filling, and intricacy.

If you’re looking to book a wedding, please fill out our wedding order inquiry form. Thank you!

Round & Heart Cakes

Below are our base prices for our round and heart-shaped cakes. Minimalistic designs (ex. top and bottom cake borders) will be near the base price range. Buttercream floral cakes and other intricate “vintage style” piping are priced $25-$65+ higher than base prices, depending on size of cake and level of work. Each custom order is priced individually based on the size of the cake, cake flavor & fillings, and decoration. The final price will depend on size, flavor, design, and details of intricacy (piping, sugar pearls, bows, edible butterflies, edible glitter, white chocolate lettering, fondant toppers, etc.). All cakes are decorated with buttercream.

4 inch 3 layer cake - starts at $40+ (4-6 servings, or smash cake)

6 inch 2 layer - starts at $50+ (8-10 servings)

6 inch 3 layer - starts at $65+ (12-14 servings)

8 inch 2 layer - starts at $80+ (16-20 servings)

8 inch 3 layer - starts at $95+ (20-24 servings)

Tiered cakes

We currently offer two options on our menu for tiered cakes. Each tier contains 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling. If you need a tiered cake to serve more guests, please choose the “Larger Tiered Cake” option on our order inquiry form and include how many guests you are serving. We can then provide you some options on cake sizing. Currently, 3 tiered cakes are available for delivery only. Delivery is strongly recommended for 2 tiered cakes. If you choose to pick up your tiered cake instead of having it delivered, you are fully responsible for the care & condition of the cake once it has been picked up. Delivery is available outside of normal delivery times and delivery zones.

Small: 4 inch + 6 inch - starts at $120+ (18-20 servings)

Medium: 6 inch + 8 inch - starts at $175+ (32-38 servings)

For larger tiered cakes, please choose the “Larger Tiered Cake” option on our order form and include how many guests you are serving. If you’re looking for a tiered cake for a wedding, please fill out our wedding order inquiry form.

Sheet Cakes

Pricing varies depending on design. Buttercream floral cakes and other intricate “vintage style” piping are priced $25-$65+ higher than base price, depending on the level of work.

Quarter sheet cake, 2 layers - $85 (20-24 servings, or 54 wedding servings)

Smash Cakes

We offer our 4 inch 3 layer cakes as an option for smash cakes for first birthdays. Prices range from $45-65+, depending on the level of intricacy.

Tiered Cakes

cake flavors

standard cake flavors

Vanilla

Chocolate

White Almond

Lemon

Confetti

Red Velvet

specialty cake flavors

Specialty cake flavors incur an additional charge of $5-$10, depending on the size of the cake.

Marble

Carrot

Strawberry

Earl Grey

Matcha

cake fillings

Fillings marked with a '*' incur a $3-$10 charge, depending on the size of the cake.

Vanilla Buttercream

Vanilla Bean Buttercream*

Chocolate Buttercream

Cream Cheese Flavored Buttercream

Lemon Buttercream

Almond Buttercream

Espresso Buttercream

Raspberry Buttercream*

Strawberry Buttercream*

Lavender Buttercream*

additional fillings

You may choose an additional cake filling if you would like. Additional fillings incur a $3-$10 charge, depending on the size of the cake.

Raspberry Preserves

Strawberry Preserves

Lemon Curd

custom cake inquiry

Interested in a delicious custom cake? Fill out some info and we will be in touch shortly! We can't wait to hear from you!

Please note that submitting an inquiry form does not guarantee a reservation. Full payments must be made to confirm your order date.

If you haven’t heard from us after 72 hours of submitting your request, please check your spam folder and add info@squaresbakes.com to your safe senders list.

If you’re looking to book a wedding, please fill out our wedding order inquiry form. Thank you!

customer information

Name

First Name

Last Name

Email will be the primary method of contact. Please ensure you enter your email correctly or we will be unable to contact you.

Phone

Primary method of contact will be email. Phone will only be used for emergency contact.

(###)

###

####

Fulfillment details

How would you like to pay?

Once your order is accepted and cake details have been confirmed, you will then be sent a payment invoice of your choice. Full payment is required to confirm your order and requested date.

Pick-up or Delivery

Pick-up is available in Livermore. Delivery fee will vary based on location. Delivery is available in Livermore & Pleasanton. For tiered cakes, delivery is strongly recommended (and required for 3 tiered cakes) and delivery is available outside of standard delivery areas.

Date needed

YYYY

Desired pick-up/delivery time

Please choose a 30 minute window to pick-up your cake. Pick-up is available for all times listed. Deliveries are only available before 11 a.m. (Tiered cakes are available for delivery all day).

Cake details

Cake Size

Cake Flavor

Flavors marked with a '*' indicate an additional charge of $5-$10, depending on the size of the cake.

Cake Fillings

Filling will go in the middle of each cake layer. Fillings marked with a '*' incur a $3-$10 charge, depending on size of cake. All cakes are iced and decorated with vanilla buttercream unless otherwise requested.

Additional Cake Fillings

You may choose an additional cake filling if you would like. Additional fillings are optional and incur a $3-$10 charge, depending on the size of the cake. Please leave blank if you are not interested.

Please describe your cake theme &/or color scheme

Please describe the decoration you are hoping to achieve in as much detail as possible. Things to include: base buttercream color and any additional colors to be used, piping detail, buttercream flowers, pearl decoration, bows, etc. You can view our gallery pictures above to see the types of cakes we typically do (buttercream florals and vintage style). Please note: I do not offer character themed cakes or fondant covered cakes.

Message, age, or name on cake

Does your cake require a special message, name or age? Let us know in the field below. Please note that if nothing is provided we will assume that you don't wish to have a message, name or age on your cake. Please keep in mind, decorative piping may be smaller if you would like a message or name included.

Any allergies?

We do not bake in an allergen-free environment. All of our products are baked in an environment where wheat, milk, peanuts, tree nuts, eggs and soy may be present. We implement strict cleaning strategies to prevent cross contamination, but cannot guarantee any product is allergen free as we use the same equipment to create all our products. We do not recommend consuming any of our desserts if you are allergic to wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, milk, soy, or eggs. Please read our allergen policy above. If you have any allergies, please let us know so we can let you know if they are in the cake flavors you have chosen.

View the terms & conditions

I have read and accept the terms and conditions.