Custom Cakes - Livermore, CA

Thank you for considering Squares for your next celebration!

We specialize in buttercream cakes, with a focus on vintage-style designs and intricate buttercream florals.

Our Policies

Currently booking for February and March!

Please read through our policies to understand our ordering process and pricing.

  • We book on a month-to-month basis — order forms for new months will open on the first of the previous month. Larger orders (ex. tiered cakes or 4+ dozen cupcakes) may be booked in advance. We are open for pick-ups Wednesday through Saturday. For cakes needed Sunday through Tuesday, please book for the Saturday prior. Cakes will last 5 days in the fridge if uncut. Delivery is only available on weekends for tiered cakes depending on availability and location.

    For our cakes, it is recommended to order at least 1-2 weeks in advance. A minimum of one week’s notice is required for custom cakes. We will try to accommodate any order placed closer to your event date, but there is no guarantee. Orders placed within less than a week of pick-up or paid for within less than a week of pick-up will be assessed a $25.00 rush fee.

  • Each custom order is priced individually based on the size of the cake, cake flavor & fillings, design details, and level of intricacy.

    Our starting prices are included on our menu. The starting price includes standard cake flavors and fillings, a single color of choice, simple border decoration (top and bottom border only), and an optional message piped in buttercream.

    Cakes with more detailed decoration, such as our buttercream floral designs or vintage-style piping, have higher starting prices due to the intricacy of the work and the additional buttercream required. Decorative elements such as sugar pearls, bows, edible butterflies, edible glitter, gold painting, chocolate decorations and lettering, fondant toppers, etc. will add additional charges to the order.

  • After submitting your inquiry, we will contact you within 24 - 48 hours via email to confirm your order, provide a quote, and to send an invoice.

    Please note that submitting an inquiry form and communication does not guarantee a reservation. Full payments must be made within 48 hours of receiving your quote to confirm your order date. Orders are not confirmed or scheduled for production until payment has been received in full.

    If we have not received payment from you within 48 hours, we will assume you no longer require the order and requested date. This means that your requested date will be made available again and will be booked by the first to pay for confirmation.

    Once your order is confirmed and paid for, there will be no changes to the design or flavor. Please read our full Terms and Conditions before submitting your inquiry.

  • Pick-up is in Livermore, 94550. Exact address will be provided after your order is confirmed and paid in full. Delivery is only available on weekends for tiered cakes.

    You will receive a pick-up reminder the day before your pick-up with your pick-up time and address.

    If you are unable to pick-up your order in the agreed upon time slot, please contact info@squaresbakes.com ASAP to arrange a different pick-up time.

    The sooner you reach out to us, the easier it will be for us to arrange a time to get your treats to you. We understand plans may change and strive to resolve these issues to the best of our ability.

    Please only show up during your agreed upon pick-up window. We allow a 15 minute grace period after your scheduled window. If you will not be able to make your pick-up window or the grace period, please contact us via email (info@squaresbakes.com) to reschedule your pick-up. Otherwise, your order will not be ready.

    Once the cake is picked up, we are no longer responsible. Please ensure you follow the transportation and storage guidelines that are sent to you before pickup.

  • We do not bake in an allergen-free environment. All of our products are baked in an environment where wheat, milk, peanuts, tree nuts, eggs and soy may be present. We implement strict cleaning strategies to prevent cross contamination, but cannot guarantee any product is allergen free as we use the same equipment to create all our products.

    We do not recommend consuming any of our desserts if you are allergic to wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, milk, soy, or eggs.

    Please read our full allergen policy. If you have any allergies, please let us know so we can let you know if they are in the cake flavors you have chosen. It is your responsibility to make any allergies known.

Round & Heart Cakes

Below are our starting prices for our round and heart-shaped cakes. Please view our “Pricing” information in our Policies above to understand what starting price includes and potential add-ons.

All cakes are decorated with vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream. Buttercream floral decorations are done in American buttercream. Serving sizes are estimates and will vary depending on how you cut your cake. If you would like larger servings, stick to the lower end of servings provided.

We’ve had to make some changes to our cake prices due to the rising costs of ingredients like butter, eggs, cocoa, and more. We truly appreciate your understanding and continued support.

4 inch 2 layer cake - starts at $40+ (4-5 servings, or smash cake)

vintage & floral cakes - start at $50

6 inch 2 layer - starts at $70+ (8-10 servings)

vintage & floral cakes - start at $85

6 inch 3 layer - starts at $80+ (12-14 servings)

vintage & floral cakes - start at $95

8 inch 2 layer - starts at $100+ (16-20 servings)

vintage & floral cakes - start at $120

8 inch 3 layer - starts at $115+ (20-24 servings)

vintage & floral cakes - start at $135

10 inch 3 layer - starts at $140+ (35-38 servings)

vintage & floral cakes - start at $175


Tiered cakes

We currently list two standard options for tiered cakes on our menu, but we can offer more custom sizing options based on your guest count and event needs. If you need a larger or differently sized tiered cake, simply select the “Custom Tiered Cake” option on our order inquiry form and let us know how many guests you plan to serve. From there, we’ll provide custom size and pricing options tailored to your event. Delivery is strongly recommended for 2 tiered cakes and 3 tiered cakes are available for delivery only. Delivery is only available on weekends for tiered cakes depending on availability and location. If you choose to pick up your tiered cake instead of having it delivered, you assume full responsibility for the care & condition of the cake once it leaves our premises.

Mini 2 Tier - starts at $125+ (14-16 servings)

Standard 2 Tier - starts at $200+ (32-38 servings)

If you don’t see the size you need, we’re happy to work with you on a custom cake that fits your event perfectly. Please choose the “Custom Tiered Cake” option on our order form and include how many guests you are serving.

If you’re interested in a wedding cake for 2026, please fill out our wedding order inquiry form as there are a few more details we’ll need from you. Thank you!

cake flavors

standard cake flavors

Vanilla

Chocolate

White Almond

Lemon

Confetti

Red Velvet

specialty cake flavors

Specialty cake flavors incur an additional charge of $5-$15+, depending on the size of the cake.

Marble

Carrot

Strawberry


cake fillings

Fillings marked with a '*' incur a $5-$15+ charge, depending on the size of the cake.

Vanilla Buttercream

Vanilla Bean Buttercream*

Chocolate Buttercream

Cream Cheese Flavored Buttercream

Almond Buttercream

Espresso Buttercream

Lemon Buttercream

Matcha Buttercream*

Raspberry Buttercream*

Strawberry Buttercream*

additional fillings

You may choose an additional cake filling if you would like. Additional fillings incur a $5-$15+ charge, depending on the size of the cake.

Raspberry Preserves

Strawberry Preserves

Lemon Curd

Toasted Almonds

Toasted Pecans

Vintage Style Cakes

All vintage cakes are decorated with Swiss meringue buttercream. Available in round, heart, or sheet cakes.

Floral Cakes

All floral cakes are decorated with hand-piped buttercream flowers. Available in round, heart, or sheet cakes.

Tiered Cakes

custom cake inquiry

Interested in a delicious custom cake? Fill out some info and we will be in touch shortly! We can't wait to hear from you!

Please read our full “Policies” above before inquiring.

After submitting your inquiry, you will be contacted within 24 - 48 hours. Please note that submitting an inquiry form and communication does not guarantee a reservation.

Full payments must be made within 48 hours of receiving your quote to confirm your order date.

If you’re looking to book a wedding, please fill out our wedding order inquiry form as we will need more information about your event. Thank you!